Canadian pro-life leaders are renewing calls for an investigation into the possibility that babies are routinely being left to die in the country after failed late-term abortions. According to official data from Statistics Canada, as many as 182 babies died after they were born alive following late-term abortions in 2013-14, a 16 per cent increase over 2011-12. The latest data was again discovered by pro-life blogger Patricia Maloney.
The information drew calls for Canada to pass its own version of the “Born Alive Infant Protection Act” that is in place at both the federal and state levels in the U.S.
“These numbers testify to the gruesome reality of children who are potentially being born alive and left to die or killed,” Jack Fonseca of Campaign Life Coalition told LifeSiteNews. “Even according to Canadian law, as corrupt as it is, that would be murder. We need a born alive protection act in Canada.”
When Maloney released her first round of findings on born-alive abortees in 2012, three Conservative MPs requested the RCMP investigate the phenomenon as suspected infanticides. But the office of one of the MPs, Maurice Vellacott, told LifeSiteNews that, more than two years later, “we haven’t received any satisfactory responses” to that request.
That leaves as a mystery what happened and continues to happen to babies that survive abortions in Canada.
Are they actively killed or left to die?
Calls to hospitals in British Columbia and Toronto’s Morgentaler Clinic for their protocols related to treatment (or disposal) of abortion survivors drew no response by press time. But when the issue was raised in 2012, the National Post reported that unnamed “doctors maintain that (late-term abortions) are performed almost exclusively in cases where the fetus has developed an unsurvivable anomaly, such as the absence of a vital organ — or in cases where proceeding with the pregnancy poses a risk to the mother’s life.”
The story went on to emphasize that these fetuses qualify for the “livebirths” category uncovered by Maloney by showing the faintest sign of life, “be it a momentary heartbeat, a sudden gasp or, in rare cases, crying.” One of the official collectors of data, the Canadian Institute for Health Information, described the following hypothetical case to instruct health information filers: when an unborn baby is diagnosed with fetal anencephaly (with no brain) and aborted at 23 weeks, the “fetus was born alive and survived one hour” – and classified with “livebirths resulting from termination of pregnancy.”
The Post found many doctors dismissing the concerns about babies being left to die but only one willing to go on the record: Dr. Douglas Black, president of the Canadian Society of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists. He said babies who show life are simply “allowed to pass away, depending on what the circumstances are, sometimes in their mom’s arms.”
Nonetheless, according to CIHI, at least 161 babies were delivered live after abortion attempts in Canada in the fiscal year 2013-14, up from 158 in 2011-12. But the earlier year included numbers from Quebec, which CIHI refused to provide for 2013-2014 on orders from the province. It is safe to assume the real national number is even higher than 161 for 2013-14.
Yet according to Joyce Arthur, head of the Abortion Rights Coalition of Canada, the “born live” category is not about ‘babies born alive’ but fetuses only seconds from death that were only showing “momentary things like a twitch or a pulse in the umbilical cord, at least in most cases.” What’s more, for late-term abortions, in Canada, she told LifeSiteNews, “the standard practice is to induce fetal demise before doing the abortion,” which “perhaps… doesn’t necessarily exclude some lingering signs of life for a short time.”
As for Patricia Maloney, who publishes her statistical gleanings at run-with-life.blogspot.ca, she says nobody really knows what is happening to babies born alive in Canada. “In fact all we have is speculation, since there are no reasons attached to any of these deaths,” she states on her blogsite. “Are these livebirth babies tossed aside and left on their own, struggling to survive until they die?”
A longer version of this article originally appeared April 14 at LifeSiteNews.com and is used with permission.